How to Write a Case Study (Canadian Business School Format)
Classfyx Canada Editorial Team | Updated | 10 min read
What a case study assignment is really testing
Case assignments at Ivey, Rotman, Sauder, Schulich, Smith, Haskayne and most Canadian college business programs are not summaries. The marker already knows the case. What is being graded is your ability to make a defensible decision under uncertainty, using the frameworks taught in the course, and to communicate it the way a manager would.
That means three things drive your grade:
- Correctly identifying the real issue (not the symptom)
- Analysis that uses evidence from the case, not opinion
- A recommendation that is specific, feasible and justified against alternatives
The standard structure
| Section | Purpose | Typical share of word count |
|---|---|---|
| Executive summary | Decision and rationale in one paragraph | 5 to 8 percent |
| Issue identification | The decision to be made, its urgency and importance | 10 percent |
| Situation analysis | External and internal analysis using course frameworks | 30 to 35 percent |
| Alternatives | Two to four realistic, mutually exclusive options | 15 percent |
| Decision criteria and evaluation | Explicit criteria applied to each alternative | 15 percent |
| Recommendation | The chosen option and why | 10 percent |
| Implementation plan | Actions, owners, timeline, budget, risks and contingencies | 10 to 15 percent |
| Exhibits | Financial calculations, tables, decision matrices | Not counted |
Step 1: Identify the issue
Ask: what decision does the protagonist have to make, by when, and what happens if they do nothing? Separate the immediate issue (the decision on the table) from the basic issues (the underlying causes). A case about declining sales at a Canadian retailer may have an immediate issue of whether to close a store and a basic issue of a channel strategy that has not kept pace with online competition.
Write the issue as a single sentence that names the decision-maker, the decision and the deadline.
Step 2: Analyze the situation
Use the frameworks your course has taught, and use them to produce insight rather than to fill boxes. Common tools:
- External: PESTEL, Porter's Five Forces, industry life cycle, competitor profiles
- Internal: VRIO, value chain, financial ratio analysis, capacity and operations analysis
- Customer: segmentation, targeting and positioning; customer lifetime value
- Quantitative: break-even, contribution margin, NPV, sensitivity analysis
Every analytical claim should point to a fact or exhibit in the case. The strongest analyses end each subsection with a one-sentence "so what" that connects the analysis to the decision.
Step 3: Generate alternatives
Alternatives must be:
- Realistic given the case constraints (cash, time, capabilities)
- Mutually exclusive, so that choosing one means not choosing the others
- Distinct, not three versions of the same idea
"Do nothing" is a legitimate alternative when the case makes it plausible, and it often makes the recommendation stronger by contrast. Present each alternative in a short paragraph with its main advantages and disadvantages.
Step 4: Set decision criteria and evaluate
State the criteria before applying them. Typical criteria include profitability, strategic fit, implementation risk, time to impact, and alignment with the organization's values or regulatory context. A weighted decision matrix as an exhibit is a strong way to show the evaluation, as long as the text explains the weights.
Step 5: Recommend and justify
Choose one alternative and state it in the first sentence. Then justify it against the criteria, acknowledge its main weakness, and explain why that weakness is acceptable or manageable. Hedged recommendations ("the company could consider...") are marked down.
Step 6: Plan the implementation
Managers are graded on execution, and so are you. Include:
- Specific actions in sequence
- Who is responsible for each
- A timeline (a simple Gantt-style table works well)
- Budget or resource requirements tied to the case financials
- Key risks and a contingency for each
- Metrics that will show whether the recommendation is working
The executive summary
Write it last. It should state the issue, the recommendation and the two or three most important reasons, in about 150 words. A reader who stops after the executive summary should know exactly what you decided and why.
Nursing case studies
Nursing case studies in Canadian BScN programs typically follow the nursing process rather than the business structure:
- Assessment: relevant subjective and objective data from the scenario, organized by system or by a framework such as Gordon's functional health patterns
- Nursing diagnoses: prioritized using an accepted taxonomy and stated with related factors and evidence
- Planning: measurable goals with timeframes
- Interventions: evidence-based, with rationale and a citation for each
- Evaluation: how you would determine whether goals were met
Confidentiality rules apply if the case is drawn from a placement: use pseudonyms and remove identifying details.
Psychology case studies
Psychology case reports usually include presenting problem, relevant history, assessment methods and results, a case formulation grounded in a theoretical model (cognitive-behavioural, psychodynamic, biopsychosocial), differential considerations, and a treatment plan. The formulation is the intellectual core: it should explain how the history and assessment data fit together to account for the presenting problem.
Common mistakes
- Retelling the case in the analysis section
- Frameworks with no "so what"
- Alternatives that are not real choices
- Recommendations without numbers when the case provides financials
- Implementation sections that are a single sentence
- Exhibits that are never referenced in the text
Formatting notes
Most Canadian business schools ask for a report format with headings, 1.5 or double spacing, and exhibits at the end. Citation style is usually APA 7. Page limits are strict and normally exclude exhibits and references.
If you would like feedback on a case analysis before submission, our assignment help service includes case study review by tutors with Canadian business school backgrounds.
Want a tutor to review your draft?
Canadian tutors, transparent CAD pricing, instant quote.
Get Your Free Quote